User Comments and Ratings

From
Rating
Comment

2013-09-25

kaj823
  • Grasped and related to subject material 3
  • Manuscript evaluation was thorough and consistent 4
  • Possessed knowledge of current marketplace 3
  • Equal attention on strengths of novel as well as weaknesses 2
  • Offered clear, helpful feedback to revise and strengthen 3
  • Suggestions given were practical to author's style 3

Marlene gave very detailed written notes and she was responsive to later inquiries/questions/ideas. She also helped shape my query letter. She looked at 2 versions of my novel and her feedback was inconsistent; things she liked in one version were then criticized in the second. She also focused on what needed work and I felt I did not have a good grasp of what elements of the story were working well.


Worked On: Women's Fiction

Comments:1

Your First Name:
Your Last Name:
Your Genre:
Your Sub-Genre:
Country:
State:
Your Website: