User Comments and Ratings

From
Rating
Comment

2018-01-26

askjess
  • Grasped and related to subject material 5
  • Manuscript evaluation was thorough and consistent 5
  • Possessed knowledge of current marketplace 5
  • Equal attention on strengths of novel as well as weaknesses 5
  • Offered clear, helpful feedback to revise and strengthen 5
  • Suggestions given were practical to author's style 5

I wouldn't trust my work to anyone else!


Worked On: Science Fiction & Fantasy

2018-01-23

AbbyRR
  • Grasped and related to subject material 5
  • Manuscript evaluation was thorough and consistent 5
  • Possessed knowledge of current marketplace 5
  • Equal attention on strengths of novel as well as weaknesses 5
  • Offered clear, helpful feedback to revise and strengthen 5
  • Suggestions given were practical to author's style 5

Amanda is an excellent editor. She is as good at providing line-by-line edits as she is at pointing out global concerns. She is helpful and thoughtful and a great person to work with. It's apparent that she loves language and wants your prose to be the best it can be. Highly recommended.


Worked On: Humor

2018-01-23

Milmeag
  • Grasped and related to subject material 5
  • Manuscript evaluation was thorough and consistent 5
  • Possessed knowledge of current marketplace 5
  • Equal attention on strengths of novel as well as weaknesses 5
  • Offered clear, helpful feedback to revise and strengthen 5
  • Suggestions given were practical to author's style 5

Amanda is a great editor. She is always clear and concise with her suggestions and provides logical reasoning for any suggested changes. She's mindful of content and context, and even writing style. She helped me a lot with poetry and gave me (an amateur) valuable insight into writing in a way that strengthened my prose and gave me a different perspective on my writing. She didn't just focus on what needed work, but also what I tended to do very well, which is highly important for someone who is just beginning to write.


Worked On: Romance

Comments:3

Your First Name:
Your Last Name:
Your Genre:
Your Sub-Genre:
Country:
State:
Your Website: